top of page
Writer's pictureMark Rosenman

May 11, 1972 An A-MAYS-ING Mets Trade.



In the annals of baseball history, few trades have reverberated quite like the momentous transaction that took place on May 11, 1972. It was a deal that transcended the mere exchange of players; it marked the end of an era, the culmination of financial woes, and the beginning of a new chapter for one of the game's greatest icons.


After nearly two decades as the face of the San Francisco Giants, Willie Mays found himself on the cusp of a surprising relocation. The news sent shockwaves through the baseball world, as fans grappled with the notion of Mays donning a different uniform, one bearing the orange and blue of the New York Mets.


To understand the gravity of this trade, one must delve into the circumstances that precipitated it. Behind the scenes, the financial landscape of baseball was undergoing seismic shifts. The arrival of the Oakland A's in the Bay Area had siphoned off much of the Giants' attendance and revenue, leaving owner Horace Stoneham grappling with mounting financial pressures.


As Stoneham's fiscal woes mounted, the unthinkable became inevitable: Willie Mays, the living legend synonymous with Giants baseball, would have to find a new home. Stoneham, driven by a blend of financial necessity and a desire to secure Mays' future, initiated clandestine negotiations with the New York Mets.


The trade itself was not devoid of drama. News of Mays' impending departure leaked to the press, prompting speculation and scrutiny from coast to coast. Amidst the media frenzy, Mays himself learned of the trade while the Giants were on the road, a development that left him grappling with mixed emotions and a sense of betrayal.


On May 11, 1972, the deal was made official: Mays would be traded to the Mets in exchange for minor-league pitcher Charlie Williams. It was a moment marked by bittersweet farewells and unspoken acknowledgments of an era coming to a close.




Willie Mays' journey with the New York Mets took an unexpected turn, diverging from his illustrious career with the Giants. Despite not being in his prime, Mays brought a surge of excitement to the Mets and their fans during the 1972 season, even as injuries plagued the team. His first home run as a Met came on 5/14/72 against the Giants. His return to Candlestick Park on July 21 was a poignant moment, marked by a standing ovation and a memorable home run.




While his statistics that season fell short of his usual standards, his impact on New York's baseball scene was profound. Writers and fans alike celebrated having a living legend back in the game, seeing Mays as a beacon of hope in troubled times. However, tensions arose between Mays and Mets manager Yogi Berra over playing time and leadership roles in the clubhouse, signaling a bittersweet chapter in his Mets tenure.


As the 1973 season progressed, Mays struggled with injuries and declining performance, foreshadowing the end of his playing days. Despite the challenges, Mays remained a respected figure among his teammates, who admired his dedication and leadership. Amid rumors of retirement, the Mets announced plans for a farewell celebration, culminating in Willie Mays Night at Shea Stadium. The event drew luminaries from across the baseball world and beyond, honoring Mays' legendary career.




Although his playing career officially ended after the 1973 season, fate orchestrated a poignant reunion, further enriching the narrative of his storied career. In 1973, as the Mets clinched a spot in the World Series, destiny paved the way for Mays to return to the Bay Area, where he once reigned supreme as the face of Giants baseball. Facing off against the Oakland A's, Mays found himself back in familiar territory, albeit in a different role. Despite limited playing time, his mere presence on the grandest stage of baseball served as a poignant reminder of his enduring legacy and the profound impact he had left on both coasts of the baseball landscape. It was a fitting bookend to a remarkable career, one that had begun in the Polo Grounds of New York City and culminated under the bright lights of Oakland's Coliseum.




In the years that followed, Mays transitioned into a new role, serving as an ambassador for the San Francisco Giants and the city he had once called home.


On August 27, 2022, Citi Field hosted a ceremony to honor Willie Mays, a momentous occasion marking the culmination of a promise made decades earlier. It was Joan Whitney Payson, a key figure in Mets history, who pledged to Mays that he would be the last to don the revered uniform number 24. This symbolic gesture underscored Mays' significance to the Mets organization and its fans. Representing his father, Michael Mays participated in the pregame ceremonies alongside a distinguished gathering of former Mets players and managers. Mets President Sandy Alderson encapsulated the significance of the event, highlighting the fulfillment of a promise made half a century prior, a testament to the enduring impact of Mays on the Mets franchise.





The Willie Mays trade of 1972 remains a seminal moment in baseball history, a testament to the enduring power of the game and the indelible mark left by one of its greatest ambassadors. As we reflect on this historic milestone, we are reminded of the timeless bond between player and fan, a bond that transcends time, team allegiances, and the ever-changing tides of the sport.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page